Lexus and BMW are both known to produce premium vehicles and both share some phenomenal interior features and luxury traits. If you are thinking about which one to buy, keep reading this article which will help you better decide which brand you should go with.
Table of Contents
What’s Better? Lexus or BMW?
Lexus is usually preferred by those who desire comfort and luxury while BMW is the first choice of those who prefer faster performance and better acceleration from their vehicle.
Lexus is known for its supreme build quality, premium interior comfort, and excellent reliability. Whereas, BMWs are generally less reliable but boast a sporty look on all of their vehicles. Moreover, BMW cars offer better performance than Lexus and other Japanese automakers.
Is Lexus More Reliable than BMW?
Lexus cars are more reliable than BMW and also rank the highest in terms of reliability. Lexus ranks number three on being the most reliable automotive brand. Also, the list of top 10 reliable cars of 2021 included the Lexus NX and the Lexus GX in 2nd and 4th place respectively.
Is BMW Interior Quality Better than Lexus Quality?
Lexus has a better interior quality compared to BMW vehicles as it makes abundant use of leather upholstery, premium wood, and aluminum trim.
The interior in the BMW base model 3-Series and 2-Series has remained somewhat similar for many years and it still makes use of plastic in a lot of areas. Whereas Lexus incorporates wooden and chrome trim along with the use of soft material which gives Lexus cars an overall luxurious feel.
Which Brand is More Luxurious?
Lexus is regarded as more luxurious compared to BMW owing to its enhanced interior feel, additional safety features, and exceptional ride comfort, while BMW has focused more on performance and drivability.
Lexus primarily focuses on luxury and splendor. Even the base model Lexus IS offers a beautiful interior design and convenience features such as 8-way powered seats with lumbar support, a high-end infotainment system with easy controls, and more.
Which Brand Have More Rust Problems?
Both BMW and Lexus handle rust and corrosion very well and you will notice any signs of rust anytime soon. BMW vehicles are known to use superb quality materials on their vehicle body and frame which is rust-resistant and ensures that your vehicle does not corrode easily.
Which Brand Last Longer?
Lexus is more likely to last longer compared to BMW as German vehicles, in general, have lower reliability compared to other companies. Both Lexus and BMW last over 200,000 miles.
However, based on the reliability ranking, it is more likely that a Lexus vehicle will go longer before showing any signs of major repairs compared to BMW cars.
Is BMW Safer Than Lexus?
Both BMW and Lexus vehicles offer extensive safety features and go through rigorous crash tests to make sure that they are safe. Lexus vehicles feature better standard safety features such as Pre-Collision System, Intelligent High-Beam Headlights, Lane Assistance, and Dynamic Radar Cruise Control. These safety equipment are also present in the BMW but some are usually offered in higher trim levels.
BMW vs. Lexus: Maintenance Costs
The average cost for the Lexus routine service and repair is up to $551 while for BMW the average yearly maintenance cost is at least $1,000 and could go up to $1,700.
According to RepairPal, the BMW 330i owners can pay on average $748 on yearly maintenance costs while the BMW M5 owners should expect a yearly maintenance cost of about $1,173.
As for the Lexus IS 350, the annual repair cost is approx. $550 while for the GX 460 it is estimated to be $770.
Which Brand is Cheaper to Repair?
Lexus can be cheaper to repair compared to BMW as common replacement parts of Lexus are much cheaper than BMW. Lexus aftermarket parts are usually sourced from Japan while BMW relies on premium brands such as Bosch for replacement parts. This usually makes the replacement parts expensive for BMW and increases the cost of repair as well.
Does BMW Depreciate Faster?
German cars are known to depreciate faster and so does the BMW. On average, the BMW vehicles depreciate by 35 percent within the first three years.
According to a study by iSeeCars, the BMW 7-series has the fastest 5-year depreciation rate of about 71.1% while the BMW 6-Series and the BMW 5-Series have a 5-year depreciation rate of 68.3% and 67.3% respectively.
Which Brand Have Better Engines? BMW or Lexus?
BMW outperforms Lexus when it comes to engine specifications and performance. Despite carrying powerful engines, BMW vehicles are also more fuel-efficient compared to Lexus.
Comparing the BMW 3-Series with its competitor the Lexus IS, the 3-Series base model is powered by a 2.0-liter turbocharged four-cylinder engine that develops 255 horsepower and sprints from 0 to 60 mph in just 5.6 seconds. Whereas, the Lexus IS carries a similar 2.0-liter turbo unit but offers 241 horsepower and takes 6.9 seconds to sprint to 60 mph.
Talking about the SUV segment, the most powerful engine option offered with the Lexus LX is the 5.7-liter V8 engine which churns out 383 horsepower. Whereas, the most powerful BMW engine in the X6 SUV is 4.4-liter Twin Power Turbo V8 that develops 445 horsepower.
Comparing the fuel economy, the base model BMW 3-Series delivers 26/36 mpg city/highway whereas the Lexus IS offers 21/31 mpg.
Does BMW Have More Features?
BMW focuses more on driver’s convenience and offers extensive interior features which improve the overall driving experience.
The new BMW 3-Series comes equipped with the ConnectedDrive services which includes the car’s internet connection and allows you to connect your phone, watch, and more with the vehicle. You can also opt for the Connected Package Professional that offers Real-Time Traffic Information and On-Street Parking Information (select cities), Hazard Preview, BMW Remote Services including Stolen Vehicle Recovery, Remote Door Unlock, and Concierge Services.
What are the Most Reliable Lexus and BMWs?
According to consumer reports, the 2017 Lexus GS, Lexus ES, and Lexus NX are the most reliable models by the automaker. Whereas, for BMW the E90 3-Series is regarded as the most reliable model.
The 2017 Lexus GS, was a powerhouse of its time offering both performance and luxury along with several impressive interior and safety features. If Lexus GS is expensive, you can opt for the 2017 Lexus ES that was considered as the best mid-size luxury sedan of the year, while the Lexus NX is regarded as the most reliable SUV owing to its superb build quality, robust turbocharged engine, and advanced interior features.
Talking about the BMW, the non-turbocharged BMW E90 3-Series was considered the most reliable model. Other reliable engines by BMW include the N52 engine which was used in the 325i and 328i. Mostly, the non-turbocharged engine by BMW is considered to be reliable as well as fuel-efficient.
Which Lexus and BMWs Should You Avoid?
The Lexus models you should avoid include the 2018 Lexus LS, 2008 Lexus RX 350, and the 2007 Lexus LS 460. While the BMW models, you should stay away from include 2013 BMW X5, BMW 3-Series (2011-2013), 2017 BMW 4-Series, and the 2015 BMW X3.
Consumer Reports gave the 2018 Lexus LS a poor ranking in terms of reliability and owner satisfaction based on the number of recalls and the reported issues by the driver. Whereas the 2008 Lexus RX 350 also reported several power steering leaking, dashboard cracking, and low mileage issues. The 2007 Lexus LS 460 should be avoided due to its compact interior space, poor performance, and mileage.
The Consumer Reports also suggest avoiding the 2013 BMW X5 due to its expensive yearly maintenance while the 2011-2013 3-Series, 2017 BMW 4-Series, and the 2015 BMW X3 are all part of the CR’s list of cars to avoid due to their low reliability based on user reviews.
Does it Make Sense to Buy Used Lexus and BMW?
Buying a used Lexus or a BMW can be beneficial financially as you can expect a luxurious car with a lower price tag compared to the new cars which are usually very expensive.
Before buying a used luxury car it is important to do due diligence and have the vehicle checked by a proper mechanic. Nevertheless, buying a used Lexus is recommended as you can get an impressive luxury car at a low price and Lexus vehicles are also known to lose only 7% of their value per year compared to other regular cars which depreciate by 30% after the first year.
Buying a used BMW can be a difficult task as it may require some effort to find a model which is properly maintained. Most mechanics suggest non buying a BMW if it’s 20 years older. Nevertheless, if you find a good deal and the model is 4 to 5 years old, it is worth the shot.
Are There any Better Alternative for Lexus and BMW?
The best alternative for Lexus could be the Korean brand Genesis while an alternative for BMW includes, Mercedes-Benz or Alfa Romeo.
If you are looking for a cheaper alternative to the 2021 Lexus IS, consider going for the 2022 Genesis G70 which boasts an equally athletic exterior profile and is powered by a sturdy 365-horsepower turbo-engine. Another great option would be the 2021 Infiniti Q50 which is powered by a 400-horsepower V6 engine and starts from $36,700.
An alternative for the BMW 3-Series sedan is the new Alfa Romeo Giulia which packs a phenomenal 2.0-liter turbo engine that develops 280 horsepower and offers superb performance. The pricing is also similar to the 3-Series.
Lexus and BMW: Pros and Cons
Highly Reliable Cars: Lexus vehicles are reliable and won’t bother you with frequent mechanical or electrical repairs.
Better Comfort and Luxury: Lexus cars are better equipped with luxurious interior features and offer a comfortable drive.
Inexpensive Repairs: Lexus does not need frequent maintenance or repairs. Moreover, the yearly repair cost is a lot lower than most other luxury auto brands.
Performance: Lexus focuses more on luxury and comfort and you cannot expect speed or faster acceleration from the engine.
Less Interior Equipment: Lexus vehicles are not equipped with the latest technologies or innovative features compared to BMW.
Unmatched Performance: BMW vehicles are known for delivering exhilarating performance and acceleration.
Driver Assistance Features: BMW is popular for adding highly innovative driving assistance features to the car.
Sporty Profile: BMW vehicles always boast an athletic and sporty persona which is not usually found in its rivals.
Low Reliability: BMW ranks lower than most of its competitors in reliability.
Expensive maintenance: You can expect a high yearly maintenance cost and frequent repair from your BMW.
Buy BMW If…
You should buy a BMW if you love driving your car at high speed and you are expecting a thrilling performance from your car as well as modern driving assistance features.
Buy Lexus If…
If you are someone who enjoys a comfortable and luxurious ride around the town, then buying a Lexus will suit you. You can conveniently drive your Lexus for up to 6 or 7 years before you see any signs of major repair.