Is 1.9 TDI a Good Engine? What Problems Does it Have?

Table of contents

Within the Volkswagen Group, there are many engines in its catalog and they can range wildly. You can go from a tiny 1.0-liter three-cylinder to the mighty quad-turbocharged W16 found in the Bugatti Chiron.

Amongst these engines is the 1.9 TDI, a widely used diesel that was one of the backbone powertrains amongst VW’s many brands but is it much good, and what sort of issues should you look out for?

Is 1.9 TDI a Good Engine?

The 1.9 TDI is a fairly nice engine to have under the hood. For one thing, it’s resilient and not liable to massive failures. However, as with any diesel as their very nature means a lack of smoothness compared to petrol engines.

What are the 1.9 TDI Versions?

There are a lot of options on how much horsepower you wanted out of the 1.9 TDI. Since it was meant to cater to a large number of different cars of varying weight, different amounts of power were needed. You could get it with the following power outputs.

  • 74bhp
  • 89bhp
  • 99bhp
  • 103bhp
  • 114bhp
  • 129bhp
  • 148bhp
  • 158bhp

As for which ones are best, it’s best to leave out the very low-power versions. Even on the small cars, they were used in, there’s not a lot of shove. Mileage could be very good, but the 103bhp option is where you should probably start. Really though, it’s around 114bhp versions where it finally feels like you’ve got some muscle.

Rather famously, the 129bhp option was the one used in the first Skoda Fabia RS as an offbeat diesel hot hatch. It wasn’t the sharpest to handle, but it had some good puff to it and the running costs were noticeably lower than petrol-powered rivals.

Read it: 3 Worst Ford Diesel Engines

In Which Cars is the 1.9 TDI Used?

The 1.9 TDI has seen wide use across the many brands within Volkswagen Group’s influence. It can be found in Volkswagens, Audis, Seats, and Skodas. However, to make it easier, I’ll list off all the cars it found a home in.

  • Audi A3 (Mk1 and Mk2)
  • Audi A4 (Mk1, Mk2 and Mk3)
  • Audi A6 (Mk1)
  • Ford Galaxy (Mk1)
  • Seat Alhambra (Mk1)
  • Seat Ibiza (Mk2, Mk3 and Mk4)
  • Seat Cordoba (Mk2)
  • Seat Leon (Mk1 and Mk2)
  • Seat Altea
  • Seat Toledo (Mk2 and Mk3)
  • Skoda Fabia (Mk1 and Mk2)
  • Skoda Octavia (Mk1 and Mk2)
  • Skoda Superb (Mk1 and Mk2)
  • Skoda Roomster
  • Volkswagen Polo (Mk4)
  • Volkswagen Caddy (Mk3)
  • Volkswagen Golf (Mk4 and Mk5)
  • Volkswagen Golf Plus (Mk1)
  • Volkswagen Sharan (Mk1)
  • Volkswagen Bora/Jetta (Mk4 and Mk5)
  • Volkswagen Passat (Mk5 and Mk6)
  • Volkswagen Touran (Mk1)
  • Volkswagen New Beetle

With its wide array of power choices, the little diesel was very flexible in what car it could be used in. Hatchbacks, family saloons, MPVs, and even the odd hot hatch wound up using the 1.9 unit. It also served as the basis for a few economy-focused cars, like the Golf Bluemotion and Superb Greenline.

How Long Does the 1.9 TDI Last?

1.9 TDI lasts long thanks to some very resilient quality on Volkswagen’s part and even longer if the engine is well maintained and serviced. You could very easily make it past 200,000 miles with a 1.9 engined car. In a lot of cases, there are cars with more than 300,000 miles on the clock, but even that’s not the full potential of the 1.9 TDI.

As long it’s well cared for, you might see it make it past the 500,000-mile mark! Truth is, you won’t be needing to worry about it withering faster than a 70s supercar. Diesel engines like this one are meant for demanding, and long term use.

Also read: TSI vs TDI. Which Engine is Better? (Comparison)

What are the Most Common Problems with 1.9 TDI?

The most common problems with 1.9 TDI are oil leaks thanks to the valve cover gasket and injector failures.

It may be one of the longest lasting-engines out there, but there are some problems to be aware of just in case. The most prevalent of these is oil leaks thanks to the valve cover gasket. It’s not a gigantic worry, but it’s something that will need fixing quickly should you encounter it.

Another issue is injector failure. If they get clogged or suffer from leakage, then the fuel economy takes a nosedive. Fixing such troubles can be done to save money, but replacing the injectors entirely might be best. That way, you eliminate the chance of the problem reoccurring and after all, you should have fuel injectors replaced at least once in the engine’s lifespan.

Trending Video: How to Easily Bring Back to Life any Old Car Battery and Save Tons of Money (click to watch)

Is the 1.9 TDI Cheap to Maintain?

It certainly is for a number of reasons. The reliability I mentioned is one of them, but efficiency also has its role. Should you go for the Superb Greenline or Golf Bluemotion I mentioned earlier and there will be smaller fuel bills as well as low maintenance costs.

So good is the 1.9 TDI’s endurance, you could even run one for a long time with little to no maintenance. While this isn’t advised (the risk of component failure does get raised), it does stand as a testament to the tough-as-a-brick quality involved here.

Read it: 10 Best BMW Diesel Engines (and Cars That Use Them)

Is the 1.9 TDI Loud?

It’s not the loudest of diesel engines to roam the Earth, but it’s not exactly silent. Perhaps one of the biggest drawbacks of the engine is its loud clattering. Although it’s not anywhere near to being deafening, it’s far from the most muted of engines.

One way of mitigating the problem would be going for a newer car that uses the 1.9 TDI. The more modern cars feature better sound deadening, so a Volkswagen from the late 2000s fitted with it, for example, would be a less noisy experience to a late 90s/early 2000s Volkswagen.

Does the 1.9 TDI Have Lots of Spare Parts?

Since it was used in so many vehicles throughout several brands, replacement parts are very common. Seeing how it’s been put in Polos and Golfs, some of the most popular and widely used cars out there, coming across new parts online or from specialist garages won’t be hard.

Does the 1.9 TDI Consume a lot of Fuel?

No, it doesn’t, quite the opposite in fact. Volkswagen’s intention with the engine was to supply its cars with something that was solid and economical. It’s why it was an excellent candidate to be used in eco-focused cars.

On average, the engine can easily break past 50mpg and several cars, you can make it past 60mpg, so as far as thirstiness is concerned, the 1.9 TDI much prefers to sip rather than gulp its fuel.

Also read: Are Volkswagens Expensive to Fix? (The Costs)

What are the Best Alternatives to a 1.9 TDI?

The 1.9 TDI was one of the best diesel engines on the market when it was new (the current 2.0-liter TDI unit replaced it in the early 2010s). As a result, there aren’t a lot of options that are on the same footing, but that’s not to say there’s none. One that comes to mind is the 1.8 TDCi DuraTorq engine from Ford.

Found in the Focus, S-Max, Mondeo, C-Max, and Galaxy, it provided decent refinement and enough power to stop it from being sluggish. Mileage is excellent too and since this Ford I’m talking about, long-term reliability is all but assured.

Another worthy choice is the 1.6 DLD engine, also of Ford origin. This one features even greater reliability than the 1.8 and has been used in a massive array of cars and not just Ford’s own. Volvo, Mazda, Suzuki, Mini, Citroen, and Peugeot have all used it in many of their vehicles.

With such an enormous usage, spare parts are in large supply and similar mileage to the Volkswagen made unit, it’s undeniably a brilliant alternative.

Conclusion

I hope you found this guide helpful and understood a bit more about Volkswagen’s useful little diesel engine. The 1.9 TDI is a near-perfect all-rounder, offering enough power to not feel gutless and competitive fuel mileage. Its engineering masterclass in durable motoring leaves it a prominent diesel engine to go for and its use in so many types of vehicles just displays its flexibility.

True, there are a few mechanical problems to look out for and there are other engines like it that can do an equally good job, but to answer the main question – is the 1.9 TDI a good engine – the answer is yes. For those seeking something that’s great for cost-efficient, dependable driving, this is one of the best for such a task.

Similar Posts